One idea, in numbers
A monthly SIP of ₹10,000 that stops at the same date, but starts five years later, ends with a lot less than the arithmetic of "five years' fewer instalments" suggests. The early years do most of the work because they have the longest to compound.
The tables below are arithmetic, not forecasts. They assume a fixed annual return compounded monthly, with each ₹10,000 invested at the start of the month, and no tax or fees. The rates (8%, 10%, 12%) are round assumptions and not a prediction of what any fund will earn.
Same end date, different start
Say the goal is the date you turn 60. Starting at 25 gives 35 years of SIP; at 30, 30 years; at 35, 25 years; at 40, 20 years.
| Start age | Years | Invested | At 8% | At 10% | At 12% |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 35 | ₹42 lakh | ₹2.31 crore | ₹3.83 crore | ₹6.50 crore |
| 30 | 30 | ₹36 lakh | ₹1.50 crore | ₹2.28 crore | ₹3.53 crore |
| 35 | 25 | ₹30 lakh | ₹95.7 lakh | ₹1.34 crore | ₹1.90 crore |
| 40 | 20 | ₹24 lakh | ₹59.3 lakh | ₹76.6 lakh | ₹99.9 lakh |
At 12%, the five years between 25 and 30 cost ₹2.97 crore of final corpus and saved only ₹6 lakh of contributions. Starting at 40 instead of 25 more than halves the investment total (₹24 lakh against ₹42 lakh) but leaves under a sixth of the final sum (₹99.9 lakh against ₹6.50 crore).
The lower the return, the smaller the penalty. At 8%, a five-year delay costs ₹81 lakh. The cost grows with the rate because that is what compounding does.
The catch-up bill
The usual reply is to invest more later. How much more?
| Delay | SIP needed to match the 35-year corpus | At 8% | At 10% | At 12% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | vs ₹10,000 | ₹15,391 | ₹16,796 | ₹18,401 |
| 10 years | vs ₹10,000 | ₹24,120 | ₹28,614 | ₹34,228 |
At 12%, a five-year delay means a monthly SIP 84% higher to arrive at the same place. A ten-year delay means 3.4 times the amount. Catching up is possible, but it needs a bigger share of income, and income is exactly what is scarce early on.
Two things the tables hide
Returns are not smooth. The numbers assume the same return every year. Real equity returns do not arrive that way. Our October SIP post shows 3-year SIPs in the median large-cap fund at 0.34% a year, and small caps at 10.42%. Long SIPs average through that, but a short one may not. The case for starting early is the arithmetic of time. It is not a promise of 12%.
The first instalment does not have to be big. A ₹2,000 SIP started now is a habit; a ₹10,000 SIP started in five years is a plan. A step-up helps close the gap: raising the SIP each year as pay rises. See step-up SIPs and the step-up calculator.
Check your own numbers
The SIP cost of delay calculator lets you change the amount, the return and the delay. The SIP calculator gives the plain future value, and how long to build ₹1 crore with a SIP works backwards from a target.
None of this is a recommendation of any fund, rate or amount. It shows why the start date matters as much as the monthly figure.
Frequently asked questions
How much does delaying a SIP by 5 years cost?
For a ₹10,000 monthly SIP continued to the same end date, a five-year delay cuts the final corpus from ₹6.50 crore to ₹3.53 crore at an assumed 12% a year, from ₹3.83 crore to ₹2.28 crore at 10%, and from ₹2.31 crore to ₹1.50 crore at 8%. The delayed investor puts in ₹6 lakh less.
How much more would I need to invest to catch up?
To reach the same final corpus after a five-year delay you would need to raise the monthly SIP from ₹10,000 to about ₹18,401 at 12%, ₹16,796 at 10% or ₹15,391 at 8%. After a ten-year delay the figures are ₹34,228, ₹28,614 and ₹24,120.
Are these returns guaranteed?
No. The 8%, 10% and 12% rates are assumptions for illustration. Actual returns vary year to year and can be negative for long stretches.
This is commentary on published data, not investment advice. WealthTicker is not a SEBI-registered adviser or distributor. Figures are as of the dates stated and can be revised by their source.
Keep reading
How to calculate your SIP's XIRR in a spreadsheet
A 12-instalment SIP in a Nifty 50 index fund, worked in Excel: the cash-flow table, signs, dates, =XIRR(), and why it shows -14.56% when the loss was 8.2%.
Car on EMI now, or invest the EMI and buy later?
Saving ₹2 lakh plus a ₹19,908 EMI at 7% buys a ₹10 lakh car in 42 months as its price rises 5% a year, leaving ₹1.35 lakh by month 48. The cost is the wait.
Interest-free home loan with a SIP: does the maths hold?
On ₹50 lakh at 8.5% for 20 years, a ₹5,419 SIP at 12% grows to the ₹54.1 lakh of interest. Earn 10% and it is ₹12.6 lakh short. What the idea assumes.
